Should Allowance Be Tied to Chores? Pros, Cons, and What Experts Say

Few parenting topics spark more debate than this: should children earn their allowance by completing chores, or should allowance be separate from household responsibilities?

Both approaches have strong advocates, and the research isn't definitive. Let's explore both sides so you can make the best decision for your family.

The Case FOR Tying Allowance to Chores

Arguments in Favor

1. Teaches the work-money connection

In the real world, you work and get paid. Chore-based allowance mirrors this reality.

2. Builds work ethic

Children learn that money comes from effort, not entitlement.

3. Creates accountability

Clear expectations: do the work, get the pay. Skip the work, miss the pay.

4. Prepares for employment

Job performance affects compensation—this is the earliest version of that lesson.

How it works in practice:

• List specific chores with assigned values
• Pay only for completed work
• Inspect before paying
• No work = no pay

The Case AGAINST Tying Allowance to Chores

Arguments Against

1. Family members should contribute regardless

Household responsibilities aren't optional. You shouldn't pay for expected participation.

2. Separates lessons

Allowance teaches money management. Chores teach responsibility. Combining them muddies both.

3. Creates transactional relationships

"What will you pay me?" shouldn't be the response to every request for help.

4. Can backfire

Some kids will choose not to do chores if they don't need the money that week.

How it works in practice:

• Allowance is given regularly regardless of chores
• Chores are required family contributions
• Failure to do chores has non-financial consequences
• Money management is taught separately

What the Experts Say

Financial education experts are divided:

Dave Ramsey: Strong advocate for commission-based pay. "Work, get paid. Don't work, don't get paid."

Ron Lieber (NYT "Your Money" columnist): Recommends separating allowance from chores. Allowance is for learning money management.

Beth Kobliner (author, "Make Your Kid a Money Genius"): Suggests a middle ground with base allowance plus earning opportunities.

The Hybrid Approach (Recommended)

Many families find success with a combination:

Base Allowance (Not tied to chores)

• Weekly amount given regardless of chores
• Used for money management practice
• Teaches budgeting, saving, spending decisions

Core Chores (Expected, not paid)

• Regular family responsibilities
• Making bed, cleaning room, helping with dishes
• Part of being a family member

Extra Earning Opportunities (Tied to extra work)

• Above-and-beyond tasks
• Car washing, garage organizing, deep cleaning
• Paid at agreed-upon rates

Why This Works

It teaches multiple lessons:

• Money management (through base allowance)
• Family responsibility (through core chores)
• Work-income connection (through extra earning)

It avoids pitfalls:

• Kids can't opt out of family responsibilities
• They still learn that extra work = extra money
• Money management learning continues regardless

Making Your Decision

Consider your values and goals:

Choose tied-to-chores if:

• Work ethic is your primary teaching goal
• You want a clear, simple system
• Your child responds well to earning
• You're comfortable withholding pay for incomplete work

Choose separate allowance if:

• You want chores to be expected, not negotiated
• Money management learning is the primary goal
• You prefer non-financial consequences for skipped chores
• Your child might use "I don't need money" to skip work

Choose hybrid if:

• You want to teach multiple lessons
• Flexibility is important to your family
• You want guaranteed money management practice
• You value both responsibility and earning

Implementation Tips

Whatever you choose:

Be consistent - Pick an approach and stick with it

Be clear - Everyone should understand the rules

Be fair - Age-appropriate expectations and pay

Be patient - Adjust as needed, but give approaches time to work

The Most Important Thing

The specific structure matters less than:

• Having intentional conversations about money
• Giving children practice managing money
• Teaching the value of work and contribution
• Being consistent with whatever you choose

There's no universally "right" answer—only what's right for your family.

Bank Roads helps kids learn essential money skills through engaging, gamified lessons—regardless of how you structure allowance at home. Join our waitlist to learn more.